Beneficiaries of the Amnesty Law believe it does not resolve the political conflict but rather advances Catalonia's independence.
The Socialist Party contradicts itself by presenting Salvador Illa as a defender of the constitution while negotiating the independence referendum.
Despite the Socialist Party's reconciliation narrative, meetings with Carles Puigdemont are not merely for amnesty supervision.
Illa's credibility as a unionist leader is compromised if his party is negotiating Catalonia's independence, harming the Socialist Party of Catalonia.
Social support for amnesty is decreasing among Catalans and the ERC refuses to acknowledge Illa as a regional leader.
Conclusion: The Socialist Party is managing a dual narrative between conciliation and separatism, creating confusion and demoralisation among its voters.